Subscription App Predictions: What Experts Expected for 2024
This page summarizes a collection of expert forecasts for subscription apps in 2024. The forecasts were derived from the publisher's State of Subscriptions benchmark data and presented as a preview of its 2024 report; this page is a secondary summary of that published commentary, not original research. The strongest signals were not about a single tactic. They clustered around three shifts: AI moving from novelty to product surface, retention work replacing broad acquisition as the main lever, and pricing and distribution rules becoming more fluid. This guide reorganizes those forecasts into a review you can run against your own app.
Three themes that ran through the forecasts
The predictions converge on three areas. First, AI appears both as a feature users pay for and as a tool that improves marketing and customer messaging. Second, several contributors argue that the next gains come from keeping the right users rather than buying more of them. Third, regulatory and platform changes create new options for distribution and payment, but the experts disagree about how quickly those options will matter. Use the three themes as a lens: for each forecast below, ask whether it changes what you build, what you charge, or how you reach users.
AI as a product feature and a marketing engine
Jenny Kay Pollock expected generative AI to keep improving the in-app experience, citing Duolingo’s Max subscription as an example of a learning product built around ChatGPT 4.0. She also pointed to AI-enhanced CRM tools, naming Aampe for personalized messaging, Canva’s Magic Tool for asset creation, and Smartling for translation quality scores. Phil Carter framed AI as a dividing line: subscription businesses whose premium content can be replicated by AI risk becoming obsolete, while those that build differentiated products and data moats could create new categories. Hannah Parvaz focused on marketing, predicting more influencer-led user-generated content and AI-generated video ads. For a product team, the practical question is whether AI changes the core value of the subscription or only the speed of producing marketing assets.
Retention: locals, first-party data, and post-trial activation
Eric Crowley’s locals-versus-tourists distinction is the most operational idea in the set. Tourists try many services and cancel often, especially when promotions attract them. Locals stay past six months on a monthly plan or past the first annual renewal, engage frequently, and pay full price. Crowley recommends measuring retention for those cohorts specifically rather than relying on the average across all users. Andy Carvell added that first-party data, collected through surveys or observed behavior, should shape paywalls, onboarding, and ongoing journeys, which requires product and marketing teams to share data rather than work in silos. Sylvain Gauchet expected falling trial conversion to push developers toward post-trial onboarding and direct-purchase options. Reid DeRamus argued that acquisition is getting harder and that retention, price, and cost control deserve more attention, while warning against over-discounting annual plans or adding lifetime plans as a short-term fix.
Pricing, plans, and paywall length
Seth Miller expected more companies to lower subscription prices and offer shorter-term plans as a response to churn on higher-priced annual subscriptions. Thomas Petit saw average subscription prices continuing to rise, citing Tinder’s $500 plan, and attributed the pressure to acquisition costs, low elasticity among a minority of payers, and premium positioning. He also expected more hybrid models that combine subscriptions with non-renewable in-app purchases, ads, partnerships, e-commerce, or affiliate marketing, and more no-trial plans for selected segments or trigger points. Jacob Rushfinn predicted longer paywalls, including multi-screen flows and pages with content below the fold, arguing that higher price points require more information before purchase. Ariel Michaeli expected more games to adopt subscriptions as a main revenue channel and consumers to become more critical about what they pay for.
Distribution, regulation, and app portfolios
Pollock expected publishers to experiment with sending users outside the app for purchases and with third-party app stores, potentially reducing platform fees. Petit was more cautious, arguing that sideloading and sales outside in-app purchase would remain scalable only for a minority of apps in 2024, even if headlines suggested otherwise. Carvell raised the possibility of an Apple OS-level ad network built around SKAN, though he presented it as a forecast rather than a confirmed plan. Jacob Rushfinn argued that scaling through user-base growth alone would get harder, and that companies would spin out related apps and cross-promote them. Steve P. Young described a portfolio approach: several apps earning $5–10K per month rather than chasing one app at $100K per month, which supports organic downloads and diversifies income. Jake Mor expected competitive advantage to come from customer support, niche problem solving, and product quality, with viral reach on TikTok helping apps that serve Gen Z. Rosie Hoggmascall expected tighter budgets to push teams toward activation, onboarding, paywall testing, discounts, CRM, and referral-driven growth.
A checklist for reviewing your subscription app against these forecasts
Use this list to turn the predictions into decisions. Mark each item as already handled, worth testing, or not relevant to your app.
- AI value check: does AI change what the subscriber receives, or only how you produce ads and messages? If it is only the latter, treat it as a marketing efficiency question, not a product strategy.
- Locals cohort review: calculate retention separately for users who pass six months on a monthly plan or the first annual renewal. Compare that figure with your overall average. If the gap is wide, your headline retention number is being diluted by tourists.
- Discount dependency test: identify how much of your recent growth came from promotions. If a large share of new subscribers arrived through discounts and cancel early, test a full-price path for a segment.
- Paywall length decision: if your price is rising, test a longer paywall with more proof and detail. If your price is low and the decision is simple, a short paywall may still be the better fit.
- Plan mix review: compare annual, monthly, and shorter-term plans against churn and revenue. Consider whether a no-trial direct purchase belongs in the mix for some users.
- Distribution watch: track regulatory changes and third-party store options, but do not assume they will scale for your app. Model the economics before committing.
- Portfolio question: if growth through one app is slowing, ask whether a related app with cross-promotion is a more realistic expansion path than further acquisition spend.
- Activation focus: review onboarding and the first purchase moment. Post-trial onboarding and clearer activation steps are cheaper to test than a new acquisition channel.
Worked example: reading a retention cohort
Suppose an app reports 40% retention at six months across all monthly subscribers. That figure mixes users who arrived through a deep discount and left quickly with users who pay full price and keep using the product. Split the group. If the full-price cohort retains at 65% and the discounted cohort at 20%, the blended number hides a strong core and a weak acquisition channel. The next decision is not to raise or lower price across the board. It is to test whether the discounted channel brings in users who later become locals, or whether it mainly adds tourists. Crowley’s advice points to the second question: measure the cohort that stays, and present that stickiness separately when discussing the business with investors.
Frequently asked questions
What were the main subscription app predictions for 2024?
The forecasts centered on three areas: AI improving both app features and marketing, a stronger focus on retention and first-party data, and adaptation to pricing and regulatory changes. Individual contributors added predictions about shorter plans, higher prices, hybrid monetization, longer paywalls, app portfolios, and niche apps.
What is the difference between locals and tourists in subscription apps?
Tourists try many services and cancel often, and they are frequently attracted by promotions or discounts. Locals are core users who engage often, share the app, and pay full price. Eric Crowley suggested measuring retention for locals, such as users who stay past six months on a monthly plan or past the first annual renewal, rather than relying only on the average across all users.
Did the experts agree on whether third-party payments would scale in 2024?
No. Jenny Kay Pollock expected publishers to experiment with purchases outside the app and with third-party app stores. Thomas Petit argued that sideloading and sales outside in-app purchase would remain a scalable option only for a minority of apps in 2024. The disagreement is useful: treat distribution changes as something to model per app rather than a universal shift.
How should a team use these forecasts now?
Treat them as hypotheses to test against your own data. Start with the locals cohort, the share of growth coming from discounts, and the fit between your price point and paywall length. Then review whether AI changes the subscriber’s experience or only your production speed. Distribution and portfolio questions come after those core retention and pricing checks.