Apple's EU DMA App Store changes: a developer decision guide
Apple's January 2024 response to the EU Digital Markets Act (DMA) gave developers in the EU a choice: keep the existing App Store business terms, or adopt a new set that opens alternative marketplaces, alternative payment routes and a new fee structure. The choice is not one switch. It is a sequence of decisions about terms, distribution and payments, and each one changes the economics. This guide walks through those decisions in the order they matter, with a worked example of the Core Technology Fee and a checklist you can use before committing.
What the DMA actually requires
The DMA is EU regulation aimed at large platforms described as gatekeepers, with the goal of fair competition in digital markets. For app developers, the practical effects described in Apple's response cover four areas:
- Third-party app stores: apps can be offered outside the traditional store, including apps Apple might not otherwise approve.
- Alternative payment options: developers can choose payment processing that may offer different terms or features.
- Data sharing: developers gain access to performance data for their ads and apps.
- Interoperability: communication apps are expected to work across different platforms and services.
The intent is to give developers more control and users more choice. Apple's implementation is optional for developers, which is why the decision below exists at all.
The three decisions, in order
Treat the change as three separate choices rather than one. Getting the order right prevents most of the confusion.
- Business terms. Stay on the old terms, or adopt the new EU terms. The old terms keep Apple's in-app purchase requirement, a 30% commission (15% for year-two subscriptions and Small Business Program members), and standard App Review for updates. Some changes, such as third-party browser engines, apply even if you do not adopt the new terms.
- Distribution. If you adopt the new terms, decide whether to stay on the App Store, distribute through an alternative marketplace, or both.
- Payments. If you stay on the App Store under the new terms, choose Apple in-app purchases, a third-party processor, or linking out to the web.
Each later decision depends on the earlier one. A payment choice, for example, only exists in the form described here if you have already adopted the new terms.
The Core Technology Fee is the hinge
Every developer who adopts the new terms is subject to the Core Technology Fee (CTF), regardless of distribution channel or payment route. Apple charges €0.50 for each first annual install beyond the first million. A first annual install counts each install, reinstall or update in a year, so the practical reading is that every user beyond the first million with the app on their phone costs €0.50 per year.
Marketplace apps do not receive the one-million free installs. A marketplace app pays for every first annual install, reinstall or update, and every app distributed through that marketplace also pays the CTF.
Worked example using the captured figures: an app with 3 million first annual installs under the new terms would face the CTF on 2 million installs, or roughly €1,000,000 per year at €0.50 each, before any commission or processing fees. An app with 1.2 million installs would face it on 200,000 installs, or roughly €100,000 per year. The same fee applies whether the app uses Apple in-app purchases, a third-party processor, or external linking. This is why the CTF, not the commission rate, is usually the deciding number.
Commission and payment routes under the new terms
Under the new terms, Apple drops its commission to 17% of in-app purchases, or 10% for small businesses and year-two subscriptions. Apps that use Apple's native in-app purchases add a 3% fee, bringing the total to 20% or 13%.
Developers who choose a third-party processor or link out to the web avoid the 3% fee but still pay the 17% or 10% commission plus whatever the third-party processor charges. They also follow additional guidelines: before a third-party purchase or an external link, the app must show a warning screen telling users the payment is not going through Apple's native system.
Apps distributed through alternative marketplaces cannot use Apple in-app purchases and must use a third-party processor.
Alternative marketplaces and what review still applies
Alternative marketplaces function as full replacements for the App Store, with their own review, guidelines and business models. Apps distributed through them pay no Apple commission on in-app revenue, but they still pay the CTF.
Marketplace apps themselves do not go through App Review, which frees them from Apple's App Review Guidelines and opens the door to new app categories. Every app distributed through a marketplace must still pass Apple notarization and human review for malware, viruses and security issues. Users also see an Apple-generated summary of the app's metadata drawn from that process.
One operational detail matters for blended distribution: iOS keeps only one version of an app on a phone at a time. If a user has the App Store version and wants the marketplace version, they must delete the App Store copy manually first. The marketplace install does not replace it automatically.
Is adopting the new terms worth it?
The original analysis is blunt: as it stood at publication, it was hard to recommend that anybody accept the new terms, because the Core Technology Fee represented too much risk for too little upside for 99.99% of the people reading that article. That is the source's own editorial judgment, not a measured outcome, and it should be read alongside the niche cases it identified.
Nico Wittenborn, presenting during the source's live panel discussion, pointed to a few narrow opportunities where the new terms might pay off:
- Low install volume with high average revenue per user (ARPU), where the CTF is small relative to revenue.
- Game marketplaces, where a high one-time fee per app can lessen the Core Technology Fee's impact, even in years after the first.
- A third opportunity for some entrepreneurial types: the release of 600 new APIs by Apple, which could lead to new third-party integrations and applications.
Predicting outcomes is challenging without benchmarks for these new scenarios. The source also reported that some groups were already complaining to the EU that Apple's rules do not fully comply with the DMA, and that the rules were subject to change in the coming months. Its stated recommendation at that point was to sit tight and wait to see what happens.
Pre-commitment checklist
Before accepting the new terms, work through these in order:
- Estimate first annual installs, including reinstalls and updates, and subtract one million if you distribute on the App Store.
- Multiply the remainder by €0.50 to get the annual CTF exposure.
- Compare that number to the commission savings from 30% to 17% (or 15% to 10%) on your EU revenue.
- If you are considering a marketplace, add the marketplace's own per-install CTF, which has no free allowance.
- Confirm whether you can switch back to the old terms; it is unclear whether developers can switch back later.
- Check whether any of your planned features depend on the new APIs, since those are restricted outside the EU.
- Re-check the rules before launch, because the terms were under challenge.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to adopt Apple's new EU terms?
No. Developers can keep the old business terms, which retain Apple in-app purchases, the 30% commission (15% for year-two subscriptions and Small Business Program members), and standard App Review. Some changes, such as third-party browser engines, apply even without adopting the new terms.
What counts as a first annual install for the Core Technology Fee?
Each install, reinstall or update in a year counts. Beyond the first million, Apple charges €0.50 per first annual install. Marketplace apps do not get the one-million free allowance and pay for every first annual install, reinstall or update.
Can I use Apple in-app purchases if I distribute through an alternative marketplace?
No. Apps distributed through alternative marketplaces must use a third-party payment processor. Apps that stay on the App Store under the new terms can choose Apple in-app purchases, a third-party processor, or linking out to the web.
Do marketplace apps skip Apple review entirely?
Marketplace apps themselves do not go through App Review, but every app distributed through a marketplace must still pass Apple notarization and human review for malware, viruses and security issues. Users also see an Apple-generated metadata summary from that process.
Can I switch back to the old terms after adopting the new ones?
It is unclear whether developers can switch back later. Treat reversibility as an open question and confirm it with Apple before committing.