Freemium vs. Free Trial: Building a Community That Stays Engaged
A free trial can create a break in the user experience when access ends. Shaun Steingold, founder and managing director of Momentum Labs, argues that a carefully balanced freemium model can build a larger, more engaged community instead.
The problem with a trial cliff
Before choosing a free trial, consider the moment it ends. That pause can pull people out of the experience and discourage further use. Steingold says he has never seen a free trial work across the many apps and companies he has worked with, because removing something users have been given feels negative and may reduce conversion. A related signal: about 60% of people who tap a free trial button do not actually start the trial, according to Superwall CEO Jake Mor as shared in the conversation.
Why community scale can matter more than a small paying cohort
Freemium works differently: instead of a temporary gift followed by a cutoff, it keeps a meaningful free tier in place. Steingold would rather have a community of a million people than 15,000, even if most of the million are free, because free users can add value and keep everyone plugged in. A community that is sometimes 90% free users can therefore be an asset, not just a cost.
A practical freemium checklist
The balance is the hard part. Offer enough free functionality to maintain engagement, while reserving some features for premium users. Steingold points to weight loss and wellness app Healthi, acquired by Momentum Labs, as an example where that nuance matters for building a stable, consistent community. Use this checklist: 1) Identify the free experience that keeps people returning. 2) Reserve features that clearly justify payment. 3) Check that the free tier supports community value rather than only acting as a teaser. 4) Watch whether the end of any trial or paywall moment breaks the habit you are trying to build.
Distribution and power-law growth
App stores give publishers distribution at scale from day one, a reach that previously belonged to a few large corporations. Steingold contrasts what took Coca-Cola 60 years and $20 billion to build with what an app publisher gets for free at day one. Momentum Labs also looks below the very top of the rankings, from the third spot and lower, where it reports 200% growth rather than 10-15% revenue growth for top apps and immediate competitors, describing the pattern as power law logic where growth doubles as an app moves up.
Do not forget the human impact
Metrics still matter, but they are not the whole picture. A single-minded focus on conversion rates, LTV and CAC can cause teams to miss how an app fits into people's lives and emotional journeys. Ask what moment in a user's life the app supports, what feeling it creates, and whether the free tier strengthens that journey instead of interrupting it.
| Approach | User experience | Community effect | Key risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free trial | Gives access, then removes it at trial end | May create a pause that puts users off further use | Negative experience and lower conversion |
| Freemium | Keeps a free tier available alongside premium features | Large free community can add value and keep users engaged | Free tier must be balanced so premium features remain worthwhile |
Comparison summarises arguments attributed to Shaun Steingold in the podcast discussion; figures are as stated in that discussion.
Frequently asked questions
Why might a free trial hurt conversion?
In Shaun Steingold's experience across the apps and companies he has worked with, a free trial has not worked. He argues it creates a negative experience by giving users something and then removing it, which can interrupt use and hurt conversion.
Why value a large freemium community?
A large community, even if most members use the free tier, can add value and keep everyone engaged. Steingold prefers a community of a million people over 15,000 even when most of the larger group are free users.
How should a freemium balance be set?
Make enough of the product free to sustain engagement and keep some features premium only. The Healthi example shows the balance needed to build a stable, consistent community.
What should teams look at besides conversion metrics?
Look beyond conversion rate, LTV and CAC to how the app fits into users' lives and their emotional journeys, rather than focusing only on numbers.