Hard Paywalls, Black Hat ASO, and Data Over Opinions With Steve P. Young
In a Sub Club conversation, Steve P. Young, founder and CEO of App Masters and owner of Indie App Santa, discusses tactics that distort app-store competition, the trade-offs of hard paywalls, and why repeated evidence should outweigh confident guesses. The episode is useful less as a rulebook for breaking store policies than as a reality check for teams trying to grow fairly.
Why unfair tactics still shape legitimate ASO
Young frames app growth as a simple sequence: earn downloads, then convert those downloads into customers. His concern is that the first step is not always a clean contest. Large apps may use black hat methods to manipulate search visibility, leaving smaller developers to compete without knowing how much of a rival's ranking was earned legitimately.
Two practices are singled out as especially widespread: keyword boost campaigns and purchased fake ratings or reviews. Even if a team rejects both, recognizing their presence changes planning. Keyword research should account for inflated competition, and ranking targets should not be treated as proof that every visible rival followed the same rules. The practical takeaway is awareness, not imitation: name the distortion, adjust expectations, and keep the growth plan within store policy and your own ethical limits.
Hard paywall decision checklist
Monetization choices often turn on user psychology and timing. Young argues that hard paywalls deserve testing in more apps, particularly early in growth, because a soft approach can leave revenue untested. The anxiety app Rootd illustrates the tension: presenting a paywall during a panic attack can feel poorly timed, so users could dismiss it, yet moving the paywall into onboarding doubled revenue.
Use this decision checklist before changing your own paywall:
- Identify the moment of highest intent and the moment of greatest user need; they may not be the same.
- Decide whether the core value should be gated immediately or after a first useful experience.
- Test onboarding placement separately from later in-product placement.
- Vary plan presentation and paywall length, since both can change conversion.
- Compare revenue, trial starts, refunds, and retention, not just initial subscriptions.
- Keep an escape route where blocking access would undermine the product's purpose.
Young's suggested focus is narrow and testable: experiment first with the onboarding experience and the paywall itself, including the plans shown and whether the screen is long or short.
Let repeated results settle the argument
The episode's closing principle is that a strong opinion is not evidence. Young says he waits before sharing a growth claim because a tactic that worked once may not work again. That discipline matters in both ASO and monetization: repeat the test, check whether the effect survives different apps or audiences, and only then treat it as a dependable lesson.
For teams, a useful evidence filter is to ask three questions. Was the result repeated? Was the comparison fair? Would the same choice still make sense if a competitor's inflated rankings or reviews were removed from view? If any answer is unclear, keep the idea as a hypothesis and run another test.
Frequently asked questions
Is Steve P. Young recommending black hat tactics?
Young distinguishes describing tactics he has observed from endorsing them. He says he is not promoting those strategies, while explaining how they affect competition and why legitimate teams need to account for them when planning keyword research and rankings.
When should an app try a hard paywall?
Consider the user's moment and intent. A hard paywall can suit early growth and apps where immediate commitment is central, but it may frustrate someone seeking urgent relief. Test placement in onboarding, plan presentation, length, and exit options, then judge the result with revenue and conversion data rather than preference alone.
How does Young decide whether evidence is strong enough to share?
Wait for a pattern that repeats before presenting a tactic as reliable. A single success may not generalize, so Young says he holds back sharing until he is confident the result is not a one-off.