Skip to content
AppDues
Log in
Contact salesSign up

Subscription Pricing as Product Strategy: Tiers, Consumables, and Onboarding Choices

Pricing is not a number you pick once. It is a design decision that determines who can enter your product, who can stay, and who is willing to pay for more. This guide distills a conversation with Ravi Mehta — who helped shape Tinder's multi-tier subscription system as Chief Product Officer and now advises startups on pricing, onboarding, and product strategy — into practical decisions you can apply.

Filling the demand curve

A single subscription price serves one slice of your audience well and leaves money on both sides of that slice. Users who would pay far more are undercharged; users who would pay a little are priced out entirely.

The pattern that works is layering. Multiple subscription tiers capture different levels of willingness to pay, while à la carte purchases let users pay for exactly the value they want without committing to a tier. Tinder used this combination to serve everyone from casual free users to high-value spenders across the full demand curve.

A practical checklist before you add tiers:

  • Map your audience from lowest to highest willingness to pay.
  • Identify which features are naturally one-off (good candidates for consumables) versus recurring (good candidates for tiers).
  • Check whether a lower tier cannibalizes a higher one or opens a new segment.
  • Confirm that each tier has a clear reason to exist in the user's mind, not just in your pricing spreadsheet.

Free to play, not free to fail

Opening access is often the growth engine, not the giveaway. Tinder's biggest breakthrough was going free: the open door built the network effects that make the product work at all. Monetization then happened through consumables and premium tiers for the subset of users who wanted more.

Ravi's framing is that subscription tiers act as force multipliers for microtransactions. The tier gives users a reason to stay engaged and a baseline of value; the consumable lets them spend more precisely when they want a specific outcome. Neither works as well alone.

A useful distinction when you plan this:

  • Free access creates reach and network effects.
  • Tiers create recurring revenue and a stable relationship.
  • Consumables capture high-intent moments that a flat subscription cannot price.

If your product depends on network effects, charging at the door can shrink the very thing that makes the product valuable. If it does not, free access may simply be a cost without a return.

Long or short onboarding?

There is no universal answer, and the two directions can both be right for different products.

At healthcare startup Sesame Care, Ravi found that expanding a three-step signup to twenty-five steps increased conversion by 40%. More steps gave users time to build confidence and understand what they were signing up for. At Tinder, the opposite worked: stripping onboarding down to seconds matched the product's low-commitment, high-volume nature.

The decision rule is whether friction builds confidence or kills momentum. Ask:

  • Does the user need to trust the product before committing? Longer onboarding may help.
  • Is the product's value obvious in seconds? Shorter onboarding protects momentum.
  • Are your extra steps collecting information you actually use, or just delaying the decision?
  • Have you tested the direction rather than assumed it?

A worked example from the captured evidence: if Sesame Care's three-step flow converted at a baseline rate, a twenty-five-step flow producing 40% higher conversion means the added steps paid for themselves in completed signups. That result is specific to a healthcare context where trust matters; it is not a general license to lengthen every funnel.

Narratives over numbers

Ravi's goal-setting framework is NCTs: Narratives, Commitments, and Tasks. It is a simpler alternative to OKRs that keeps teams anchored to the why, the what, and the how.

  • Narrative: the story of where the product is going and why it matters.
  • Commitment: the specific outcome the team promises to deliver.
  • Task: the concrete work that moves the commitment forward.

The framework is useful precisely because metrics alone can drift. A number tells you whether something moved, not whether it moved in the right direction. A narrative gives the number meaning.

On growth specifically, the advice is to avoid chasing vanity metrics and instead build systems that create lasting value and predictable revenue. A quick comparison:

Conclusion

Pricing, access, onboarding, and goal setting are connected decisions. Tiers and consumables let you serve the full demand curve; free access can be the engine that makes the network valuable; onboarding length should follow whether friction builds confidence or kills momentum; and NCTs keep teams pointed at value rather than at a number.

For the fuller conversation on monetization strategy and onboarding psychology, listen to the Sub Club podcast episode featuring Ravi Mehta.

Narratives over numbers
DimensionMetric-only goalNCT goal
Starting pointA target numberA story about user value
Team alignmentShared number, unclear whyShared why, what, and how
RiskOptimizing the metric, not the outcomeTied to a stated commitment
ReviewDid the number move?Did the narrative hold and the commitment land?

Frequently asked questions

Why combine subscription tiers with consumables instead of choosing one?

Tiers capture recurring willingness to pay and give users a stable relationship with the product. Consumables capture one-off, high-intent moments that a flat subscription cannot price. Together they cover more of the demand curve than either alone.

Does longer onboarding always improve conversion?

No. At Sesame Care, expanding a three-step signup to twenty-five steps increased conversion by 40%, but Tinder succeeded by shortening onboarding to seconds. The deciding factor is whether the added friction builds user confidence or kills momentum.

What are NCTs and how do they differ from OKRs?

NCTs stand for Narratives, Commitments, and Tasks. They are a simpler alternative to OKRs that keeps teams focused on the why, what, and how of their work rather than on a target number alone.

Should a network-effect product charge at the door?

Usually not. Tinder's decision to go free built the network effects that made the product work, and monetization came from consumables and premium tiers for users who wanted more. Charging at the door can shrink the network that creates the value.