Skip to content
AppDues
Log in
Contact salesSign up

Reader App Fees and Compliance: A Publisher's App Store Guide

News and magazine apps sit in an unusual corner of the app economy. Their content is often already paid for elsewhere, their subscribers usually started on the web, and the stores still take a cut of anything sold inside the app. This guide maps the routes available to publishers on Apple's App Store and Google Play, the fee each route carries, and the review traps that most often catch reader apps.

Why publishers face a different app store problem

Most publishers did not start as app businesses. The app is an additional surface for reaching readers, not the original home of the content. Subscriptions, meanwhile, have become a larger part of digital publishing revenue as advertising alone has become harder to rely on.

That combination creates two recurring problems. First, a publisher's existing subscriber base usually signed up on the web or through print, so the business model was built without a 15–30% platform commission in mind. Second, the stores restrict how an app can point readers toward an existing web checkout. A publisher that already has a payment system on its website cannot simply route new mobile readers into it.

Apple does recognise reader apps as a distinct category with its own rules. Google's approach differs in both structure and flexibility. The rest of this guide works through those differences.

What compliance actually covers

Compliance means following the review guidelines and developer policies of each marketplace. The practical consequence of getting it wrong ranges from a rejected build to removal from the store. Apple's rules, for example, generally stop apps from using their own mechanisms to unlock content or functionality.

Compliance is also a moving target. Guidelines change, and publishers need to track official updates rather than rely on how a rule was applied a few years ago. Where the commercial stakes are high, legal advice on digital commerce is worth having.

There is a customer-facing side too: people expect purchases made through a store to work, and they expect payment and personal data to be handled securely. A compliant app is one that keeps those expectations intact.

The revenue context behind the compliance question

Estimates compiled by data.ai put news and magazine app revenue growth at 23% year on year on iOS and 57% on Android between 2021 and 2022. The table below preserves those figures by region. They are a dated reference point from that period, not a current market measurement, so check present-day data before building a forecast on them.

The precise split between subscription revenue and advertising within those totals was not available. What was observable is that most top apps in the category offered in-app subscriptions. That raises the central question this guide addresses: why sell inside the app at all when a web checkout avoids the commission?

Reader apps and the External Link Account Entitlement

Apple's reader-app rule lets users access content they have already purchased or subscribed to, covering magazines, newspapers, books, audio, music, and video. Reader apps may also offer free-tier account creation and account management for existing customers.

The significant addition is the External Link Account Entitlement. A reader app that receives it may place an informational link to a website the developer owns or maintains, so users can create or manage an account there. The entitlement became available in early 2022.

The catch is decisive: an app using the entitlement cannot also offer in-app purchases. It is one route or the other. That forces a genuine trade-off. Leaving the app to pay adds friction, but it avoids the commission. Whether that is worth it depends on whether the app is mainly acquiring new readers or mainly serving people who already pay.

iOS decision checklist: in-app purchase or external link

Use this checklist to choose between the two iOS routes before you build either one.

  • Fee exposure. In-app purchases carry a commission of 15% or 30% depending on circumstances. The external link route avoids Apple's commission on the transaction, but you carry your own payment costs.
  • Checkout friction. In-app purchase keeps the reader inside the app. The external link route sends them to a browser, and every tap on that link must first show Apple's required interstitial modal sheet.
  • Subscriber data. In-app purchases let you obtain users' email addresses and associate them with their subscriptions. With the external link route you cannot track what happens after the click.
  • Store presence. If the App Store is mainly a discovery channel, the friction of an external checkout may cost more conversions than the commission saves. If it mainly serves existing subscribers, the calculus changes.
  • Mutual exclusivity. Confirm which route you are committing to, because the entitlement and in-app purchases cannot coexist in the same app.
  • Eligibility. Confirm the app genuinely qualifies as a reader app before relying on the entitlement; misclassification is a common source of rejection.

What the Which? experience shows

Which?, a UK consumer organisation founded in 1957, runs both an iOS and an Android app and is one of the few high-ranking publishers using the External Link Account Entitlement. Its path to that point is instructive.

Its head of product, Kevin Curtis, described an earlier freemium model. Roughly 20–25% of app users reached the first login screen without being able to access any content because they were not members. A limited free-access period followed by an in-app subscription converted well for a year or two. Apple then rejected the app, arguing that the value exchange behind collecting email addresses was not clear.

The underlying issue was guideline 5.1.2(x): an app may request an email address only if the request is optional and features are not conditional on providing it. Because the address was not unlocking a trial or a reader-app free tier, the purpose was not evident to the reviewer. Which? paused in-app subscriptions, let natural attrition reduce that cohort, and added journeys steering members toward its own channel. It later rebuilt the app in React Native over about 18 months.

When the External Link Account Entitlement arrived, Which? adopted it and was rejected again, this time because the app did not include its magazine content. After that content was added, Apple approved it. The subscribe link has been in the app since the start of that year; about 30% of people who download the app engage with it, though activity after the click cannot be tracked. Which? still plans to reintroduce in-app subscriptions, accepting the commission in exchange for obtaining email addresses tied to subscriptions.

Three ways to reduce Apple's commission

Apple's standard commission can fall from 30% to 15% through more than one route.

  • Small Business Program. Apps earning less than $1 million per year on the App Store qualify for the reduced rate.
  • Subscription duration. The commission on a subscription is 30% until a user has been subscribed for one year, after which it drops to 15%.
  • News Partner Program. Publishers with a channel on Apple News pay a flat 15% on subscriptions.

These levers can be combined with the reader-app decision, but each has its own eligibility conditions. Verify current terms directly with Apple before modelling revenue.

News Partner Program eligibility

Announced in August 2021, the News Partner Program is aimed at subscription news publications that supply content to Apple News in Apple News Format. Qualifying publishers can receive a 15% commission rate on eligible in-app purchase subscriptions from day one.

The key eligibility points are:

  • Publishers in the US, Canada, the UK, and Australia must publish in Apple News Format and maintain a robust Apple News channel. Publishers outside those regions who do not use the format must make content available via an RSS feed.
  • The app's primary function must be delivering original, professionally authored news content.
  • The app must offer auto-renewable in-app subscriptions through the App Store.

Whether the programme is worthwhile depends on how much of your audience already uses Apple News. One analyst estimate put Apple News+ at 19 million subscribers worldwide in 2023, up 73% on 2020. The Guardian, previously a prominent critic of Apple News, returned to the platform, citing easier generation of supporter and advertising revenue. Treat both the estimate and the platform terms as dated and check them before committing.

How Google Play differs

Google Play is generally less restrictive than the App Store, though the rules still constrain how a publisher can sell.

  • All subscriptions on Play carry a 15% service fee, regardless of revenue earned.
  • Google has no exact equivalent of the External Link Account Entitlement. The Play User Choice Billing Pilot lets developers offer alternative payment options alongside Play billing, but they still pay a 4% service fee to Google. The pilot permits web-based payments inside an embedded web view, so users stay in the app, and apps are not forced to give up in-app subscriptions. It remains a pilot, subject to change, and not every country is eligible.
  • Apps outside the pilot that let users unlock content in-app may use only Google Play's billing system, and may not tell users they can subscribe elsewhere on the web.
  • A consumption-only app, which does not let users unlock content in-app but may still gate content, may tell users they can subscribe or manage an account on the web, but may not use external links.

Review traps and how to avoid them

Spotify's audiobook launch is the clearest cautionary example. The audiobooks were sold separately from a Spotify subscription, and Apple rejected the app three times. Spotify's first approach, built with legal help, let users submit an email address to register interest in a locked audiobook; the follow-up email contained the price and a purchase link. It passed review initially and was later rejected for circumventing rules against web addresses and language encouraging purchases outside the app. The approved version removed all purchase instructions and left users at a dead end.

The lesson is that even well-resourced teams with legal support can misjudge a reviewer's reading of the rules. The practical checks below cover the most common failure points.

  • Android: do not use external links that let users subscribe, purchase, or manage an account elsewhere. Even inside the User Choice Billing Pilot, external links must open in an embedded web view.
  • iOS: do not direct users to your website to create or manage an account or subscribe unless you hold the External Link Account Entitlement, and remember that holding it rules out in-app subscriptions.
  • Both platforms: avoid any wording suggesting that subscriptions or content can be purchased off-app unless you are in the pilot or hold the entitlement.
  • iOS with the entitlement: show the required in-app interstitial modal sheet whenever a user taps an external link to upgrade or manage an account, implemented through the External Link Account API.
  • iOS: do not ship a repackaged website. Guideline 4.2 requires features, content, and UI that go beyond a web wrapper.
  • Both platforms: if a rejection still lands, appeal. Reviewers do sometimes misread an app as not being a reader app, and this happens more often on iOS than on Android.

Policy rejection versus technical rejection

Not every rejection is a compliance problem, and treating them the same wastes time.

A policy rejection means a reviewer believes the app breaks a guideline: an external link without the entitlement, unclear value exchange for an email address, missing magazine content, or a web-wrapper experience. The remedy is to change the app or the wording, or to appeal with a clear explanation of why the app qualifies.

A technical rejection covers crashes, broken flows, and performance problems. These are fixed in the build, not argued in an appeal. The compliance guidance in this guide does not address them; the stores' own developer documentation does.

Before appealing, confirm which category you are in. An appeal that argues policy on a crash rejection, or fixes code in response to a policy objection, will not move the review forward.

Putting the decision together

The choice for a publisher comes down to a small number of questions. Does the app need to acquire new subscribers inside the store, or mainly serve people who already pay? Can the business absorb a 15–30% commission in exchange for a smoother checkout and subscriber email data? Does the app qualify for a reduced rate through the Small Business Program, subscription duration, or the News Partner Program?

On iOS, the External Link Account Entitlement removes the commission but adds friction and gives up in-app purchases and post-click tracking. On Android, the 15% subscription fee is uniform, and the User Choice Billing Pilot offers a limited alternative with its own 4% fee and country restrictions. Whichever route you take, the review traps are similar: no off-app purchase language without the right permission, no web-wrapper apps, and a clear, optional purpose for any email address you request.

News and magazine app revenue growth, 2021 to 2022
PlatformGrowth and revenue by region
iOS+23% worldwide $252m in 2022 vs $205m in 2021 +51% United States $103m in 2022 vs $68m in 2021 +13% Europe $88m in 2022 vs $78m in 2021
Android+57% worldwide $127m in 2022 vs $81m in 2021 +9% United States $28m in 2022 vs $26m in 2021 +40% Europe $46m in 2022 vs $33m in 2021

Estimates provided by data.ai, covering 2021 and 2022. Dated reference figures; check current market data before relying on them.

Frequently asked questions

What is Which?

Which? is a UK organisation founded in 1957 to help consumers make informed choices about products and services. It runs both an iOS and an Android app and is among the few high-ranking publishers using Apple's External Link Account Entitlement.

Can a reader app offer in-app purchases and an external account link at the same time?

No. An app that uses the External Link Account Entitlement cannot also offer in-app purchases. The two routes are mutually exclusive, so the decision has to be made before implementation.

What commission does Google Play charge on subscriptions?

All subscriptions on Google Play carry a 15% service fee, regardless of revenue earned. Apps in the User Choice Billing Pilot can offer alternative payment options but still pay a 4% service fee to Google.

What happens if a reader app is rejected?

Appeal. Reviewers sometimes misjudge whether an app qualifies as a reader app, and this is more common on iOS than on Android. If the rejection is technical rather than policy-based, fix the build instead.