Shot Pattern: From $12K to $1M After Turning Down a $75K Offer
Eric Duffett built a golf strategy app as a hobby, then faced a buyout offer that would have ended it. He said no, survived a rough winter, and later crossed $1 million in total sales while still teaching high school full time. This page walks through the decisions that mattered: buying course data, testing ad creative, reading unit economics, and separating a failed exit from a failed product.
The $5,000 bet that changed everything
Shot Pattern began as a small tool that drew two lines on a satellite map to show the width of a landing area. It cost $20 a year. Early users opened it at home and saw it pointing at their backyard, which felt odd, but on the course it worked like a compass for shot strategy.
Within two months, downloads and trials were arriving from somewhere Eric could not identify. The explanation was simple: serious golfers were already measuring fairway widths by hand with the Google Maps ruler. The app automated a workflow that already existed in a strategy-minded community.
Then came the wall. To make the app aware of courses, holes, and hazards, Eric needed course data. The only route was a $5,000 upfront API purchase, against roughly $1,000 in total sales. His wife asked the obvious question: is this a hobby or a business?
He paid. Buried in the data were geo-point outlines of every fairway, bunker, water hazard, and green. That was the missing piece for shot simulations, the feature that would define the app.
The prototype that drew a buyout offer
Eric built a half-finished simulation prototype, took a screenshot, and posted it with a note that the feature would be highly illegal to use during tournament play but was coming soon. That post was the first time anything he published gained real momentum with a cold audience. Golf influencers and coaches started calling.
Soon after, a respected golf company called. They had used the app, liked it, and wanted to buy it. Eric asked for $250,000 against $12,000 in total sales. They countered at $75,000, with a non-compete clause added at the very end: no more golf apps, ever. He said no.
The dark winter
The high lasted about two weeks. What followed was, in Eric's words, a dark, dark hole. The sum he had walked away from would not have transformed his life, yet it would have softened the financial strain on a family welcoming a newborn. The buyers spelled out their advantage: they could rebuild what he had made, backed by wider reach, stronger brand recognition, and a developer working on it full time, while he was in a classroom and caring for a newborn. As they saw it, his run was finished.
October arrived, golf season ended, and revenue, trials, and subscriptions all dropped. After doing his taxes, Eric calculated that at his current profit rate it would take 75 years to catch up to the $75,000 he had walked away from. He tried to sell the app to someone else and got no responses. He emailed Curtis Herbert, who talked him off the ledge.
Spend a dollar, make four
The next spring, Eric tried Meta ads. He had learned from Sub Club and other podcasts that you need creative inventory and enough budget for the algorithm to learn. He paid content creators, set a $300/day budget, and at the last second added a scrappy screen recording with his own voiceover: raw, unpolished, zero production cost.
That last-second addition outperformed everything else. Cost per install was $0.80. His 30-day LTV per download was over $4. Spend a dollar, make four. He told his wife he was going to get a line of credit at the bank; she grabbed him by the collar.
The reason it worked was not sophisticated targeting. The creative did the filtering. It showed the app doing the thing strategy-obsessed golfers already cared about, in language they already used. People outside that niche scrolled past. People inside it stopped.
By the end of 2024, his first full year, Eric had outrun the $75K offer, not just in revenue but in profit and what he paid himself. He still had the app and the momentum.
$1M as a teacher with a side project
In early 2026, Shot Pattern crossed $1 million in total sales. Eric is still a full-time high school teacher. He teaches intro to business, personal finance, and next year, sports marketing. He recently showed his students a viral video he made for the app and explained his target customer profile: they look like him, dress like him, probably think like him, and are bald like him. A student raised his hand, patted his belly, and said he was working on looking more like Eric's target customer. Eric says the student did not mean anything by it, but it came off as quite the dis.
The competitor that had vowed to outbuild him never delivered the feature. Eric's first contractor was a general business operator rather than a developer, tasked with email automation, paywalls, and experiments. He is still the app's sole developer, and that part of the work still delights him. In his words, it is one of the coolest things to sit down and solve a puzzle with your mind, then show it to people and give them value in exchange for dollars so it feels like a win for everybody.
In the full episode, Eric also talks about his first failed meditation app for athletes, what he learned from working with UI/UX students, how he handles the emotional weight of seasonal revenue swings, and why he recommends The Only Way to Win by Dr. James Loehr to every high performer he meets.
A decision checklist for a buyout offer
Use this checklist before accepting or rejecting an acquisition offer for a side project:
- Separate the offer price from the non-compete. A $75,000 offer with a lifetime ban on the category may be worth less than a smaller offer without one.
- Compare the offer to your current profit rate, not just total sales. Eric calculated that catching up would take 75 years at his then-current profit rate.
- Ask whether the buyer can actually ship the feature that makes your app distinctive. In this case, the competitor never built it.
- Check whether the offer covers the next data or infrastructure purchase you need to stay competitive.
- Write down what you would do with the money and what you would do with the time. If the time matters more, the offer is not the only variable.
- Get an outside read from someone who has sold or kept an app. Eric's call to Curtis Herbert is one example.
A worked unit-economics example
The ad result is a useful template for reading a small test. With a cost per install of $0.80 and a 30-day LTV per download of over $4, each dollar spent returned more than four dollars in 30-day value. That is the ratio Eric described as spend a dollar, make four.
Two cautions apply. First, 30-day LTV is not the same as cash collected in 30 days; subscription revenue arrives over time. Second, the $300/day budget and the creative mix were specific to this app and this audience. Treat the ratio as a benchmark to test against your own numbers, not a guarantee.
Failed exit vs. failed product
A rejected offer is not the same as a failed product. In this story, the offer was declined, the app had a difficult winter with falling revenue and no buyers, and the product still recovered through a new acquisition channel. The failure was in the exit process, not in the app's value to its users.
When you evaluate a similar situation, ask which failure you are actually facing. If users still open the app and pay for it, the product may be viable even when a sale falls through. If the only path to growth requires a purchase you cannot fund, the product may be the problem.
Guest links
Eric Duffett on LinkedIn. Shot Pattern on social media. Shot Pattern app.
Frequently asked questions
Why did Eric Duffett turn down $75,000 for Shot Pattern?
He had asked for $250,000 against $12,000 in total sales. The counteroffer was $75,000 with a non-compete clause that would have barred him from building golf apps again. He said no and kept the app.
What did the $5,000 API purchase include?
It was an upfront purchase of golf course data. Beyond course and hole information, the data contained geo-point outlines of fairways, bunkers, water hazards, and greens, which enabled the shot simulation feature.
How did the Meta ads perform?
The best-performing creative was a raw screen recording with Eric's own voiceover. Cost per install was $0.80, and 30-day LTV per download was over $4, a ratio he described as spend a dollar, make four.
Is Eric Duffett still a full-time teacher?
Yes. He teaches intro to business, personal finance, and sports marketing, and he remains the sole developer of Shot Pattern.
What happened to the competitor that threatened to crush him?
The competitor never built the feature that made Shot Pattern distinctive. Eric later hired a general business operator, not a developer, to handle email automation, paywalls, and experiments.