Consumer subscription growth in 2024: rebound, retention, and Maslow's Hierarchy
Eric Crowley of GP Bullhound discusses the 2024 Consumer Subscription Software Report on the Sub Club Podcast, covering a rebound after a difficult period, ways to grow revenue from existing subscribers, and a framework for matching app features to human needs.
On the rebound
Consumer subscription software had a difficult run in 2022 and 2023 after heavy investment and hiring in 2021. Many businesses did not scale as quickly as hoped. Some responded by reducing scale and changing direction, and that reset helped set up renewed innovation and growth in 2024.
A useful way to judge your own position is to separate three questions: Are you trying to grow faster, grow more profitably from current users, or prepare for a capital event? The right move depends on which of those goals matters most, not on following the same path as every other app.
Flo: grow with users over time
Flo is used as a comeback example. The female health-tracking app had 60M monthly active users and a $1B valuation, and when seeking $100M it secured $200M after competitive interest.
The model behind that result is long-term nurturing through freemium. Users can start free at a young age, around 15 to 17, and stay in a free data layer through their 20s, 30s and into perimenopause. Paid modules are added when needs change. Even converting only 1 to 3 percent of a large free audience with each new module can produce hundreds of millions in revenue.
Checklist for applying the lesson:
- Offer a genuinely useful free starting point early in the user journey
- Build a long-term relationship rather than pushing an immediate paid conversion
- Add paid modules tied to new life stages or needs
- Measure success by lifetime value across stages, not only by early conversion
Take the next exit? Grow without raising or selling
Raising capital or selling is not required for every company. For some owners, keeping a profitable app and living from its revenue is more advantageous.
For early-stage businesses and later-stage businesses that are not for sale, net revenue retention is a practical lever. One-time purchases and add-ons can increase spending from the existing subscriber base. Tinder's baskets of superlikes are cited as a long-running example: not a subscription themselves, but they enhance product use. More targeted, customized offers — increasingly supported by AI tools — are expected to make this approach more common in consumer subscription software.
Decision check: if you do not want to raise or sell, prioritize add-ons that solve a real in-product problem, test them with current subscribers, and track whether they lift retention and revenue per user.
Maslow's Hierarchy of Subscriptions
Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs ranks human needs from basic physiological requirements such as food up to self-actualization, or realizing full potential. The report's argument is that every app meets some human need, and naming that need helps you choose features users will value.
Use this mapping as a feature checklist:
- Love and belonging: build in community functions
- Esteem: add leaderboards or recognition mechanics
- Self-actualization: keep adding new content so users can keep improving at what they are trying to do
Before adding a feature, ask which need it serves. If you cannot name the need, the feature is probably solving a product problem rather than a human one.
Conclusion
These are only highlights from the full GP Bullhound report. The complete report and the full podcast conversation with Eric Crowley contain additional findings and forecasts for consumer subscription services.
| Human need | Feature direction | Example from discussion |
|---|---|---|
| Love and belonging | Community function | Community built into the app |
| Esteem | Leaderboard | Leaderboard mechanics |
| Self-actualization | Fresh content | New content for continued improvement |
Mapping paraphrased from Eric Crowley's examples; not an exhaustive Maslow taxonomy.
Frequently asked questions
Does every subscription app need to raise money or sell?
No. Keeping a profitable business and growing from its revenue can be the better choice, especially when raising capital or selling is not the goal.
How can an app improve net revenue retention without raising capital?
One-time purchases and add-ons can increase revenue from people who already subscribe, without relying only on new subscribers.
How do you apply Maslow's Hierarchy to app features?
Identify the human need the app serves, then choose features that directly support that need — for example, community for belonging, leaderboards for esteem, or fresh content for self-actualization.