Skip to content
AppDues
Log in
Contact salesSign up

Mission and profit with freemium: how Lose It! grew organically

Lose It! reached 50 million users without making paid ads its engine. Its approach treats a strong free product as the growth channel, then earns subscription revenue from convenience, clear savings messaging and store visibility.

Authenticity as the growth foundation

Lose It! began as a calorie-counting spreadsheet and grew into a major health and wellness app with 50 million users. Its leaders, Erin Webster-Shaller, VP of Marketing, and Paul Apollo, Senior VP of Operations, frame the business around authenticity: avoid exaggerated weight-loss promises, state plainly what the product can help with, and deliver on that claim. That restraint is presented as a reason users trust and recommend the app.

Keep the free product excellent, sell simplicity

The free tier is not a teaser. It has been core since the early days and is credited with much of the growth. Premium is sold as a simplification layer: pulling data from apps and devices into one place so users get a single number to follow without extra thinking. Messaging is then tested, with discount wording that highlights savings and low premium prices performing well with a price-sensitive audience.

Organic first, paid as a small supplement

Word of mouth and organic acquisition have remained consistent across 15 years. Paid marketing is kept to a very small share of the mix, and campaigns are aimed at getting people into the free experience, where monetization can begin. App store optimization on the App Store and Google Play is treated as a major lever rather than a side task.

The paid experiment that had to be scaled back

When the team tried to move away from organic flow as the primary source of users and pushed paid acquisition hard, the economics broke down. The business stayed cashflow positive, but organic revenue was subsidizing paid spend, return on ad spend dropped to as low as 10%, and the new users brought in were not monetized. The response was to scale back and keep efforts more efficient.

A practical checklist for freemium teams

Use this checklist to judge whether a freemium push is healthy: Is the free experience valuable enough to earn recommendations on its own? Does premium remove real work, such as consolidating data, instead of withholding basics? Is savings messaging tested rather than assumed? Is store optimization funded before paid spend? And can paid cohorts monetize without being carried by organic revenue? Lose It! is also exploring referral incentives, including a sweepstakes-style approach, to reward sharing and user success, while acknowledging that referral programs bring their own challenges.

Frequently asked questions

How do you convert free users when the free app is already strong?

Keep the free tier genuinely useful and available to anyone, then sell convenience and consolidation rather than basic access. Lose It! points to combining data from apps and devices into one place with a single number to follow, and to discount messaging that stresses savings for a price-sensitive audience, tested carefully with A/B tests.

Why keep paid acquisition small?

Paid was described as a very small part of the overall mix, with marketing aimed at driving people to the free experience first. Word of mouth, organic acquisition and app store optimization on both the App Store and Google Play were the main levers over 15 years.

What went wrong with the big paid push?

A large push was scaled back after return on ad spend fell to about 10%. The company stayed cashflow positive, but the organic base was effectively subsidizing paid growth, and new paid users were not being monetized.

What comes next for growth?

Referral incentives are being explored as an alternative angle, including a sweepstakes-style idea, to emphasize user success and sharing. The discussion also covers the difficulty of referral programs and the strategy behind increasingly lengthy onboarding.