Skip to content
AppDues
Log in
Contact salesSign up

Four Paywall Redesigns and the Metrics They Moved

A paywall change is only useful if you know which number it is meant to move. The four redesigns below come from different app categories and report different outcomes: paywall-view conversion, average revenue per user, install-to-trial rate, and revenue. Read them as a set of testable levers, not a universal recipe.

How to read these case studies

Each case pairs an original paywall with a redesigned version and reports a measured result. The apps were not all measuring the same thing. A lift in paywall-view conversion is not the same as a lift in ARPU, and an install-to-trial lift is not the same as a revenue lift. Before borrowing a lever, confirm which metric your own test will read and whether the lever is available on your platform.

Case 1: A promo paywall for a crypto portfolio app

The first app is a crypto portfolio tracker converting freemium users to paid. The original promotional paywall converted 2.7% of paywall views to subscription. The redesign reached 3.24%, a lift of more than 20%.

The redesign leaned on four levers. First, it used language the audience already recognized, framing the offer like a familiar trading cue rather than a generic sale. Second, it made the discount visible: a price chart showed the deal in action, and a marker reading “Back to $15.99/month” made clear that waiting would cost more. Third, bold gradients and a “SALE” callout made the offer hard to miss. Fourth, the copy read like an inside tip rather than a company pitch, which supported trust.

Case 2: An onboarding paywall for a driver-license prep app

The second app helps users prepare for a written driver’s license exam with state-specific practice tests and DMV questions. Its original onboarding paywall was long-form: features, a free trial, social proof, success stories, and FAQs. Users who declined were then shown a weekly plan offer. The redesign shortened the paywall, added a trial toggle, pulled in real App Store reviews, and placed the weekly plan on the main screen. ARPU rose 17.02%.

The likely drivers were a trial toggle that let users choose to pay upfront, less repetition of benefits already shown during onboarding, price anchoring that displayed weekly pricing first ($14.99/week) and highlighted 40% savings on the monthly plan ($9.99/week), social proof placed near the top, and a simpler layout that reduced the amount of text to process.

Case 3: An onboarding paywall for a party game app

The third app is a party game that already converted well. Its original onboarding paywall was long-form, listed annual, monthly, and weekly plans, and placed reviews beneath the payment options. The redesign moved to a short-form layout, added a trial toggle, removed the monthly plan from the main screen while keeping it under “View All Plans,” and refined the visual hierarchy. Install-to-trial conversions rose 31% and revenue rose 64%.

The redesign also replaced a formal headline with a more playful one, reduced the plan choices to weekly and yearly, emphasized the yearly plan’s savings with “SAVE 83%,” and showed a price breakdown ($12.33/week for yearly versus $29.99/week for weekly). Playful illustrations and a clearer “Continue” button supported the game’s tone and made the next step easier to see.

Case 4: An onboarding paywall for a food app

The fourth app is in the food category and already had a solid install-to-trial start rate. Its original paywall was long-form, with three payment options, a feature list, a note from the CEO, and an FAQ. The redesign added a trial toggle, shortened the layout, featured real App Store reviews, and led with a fact about the app’s impact. Install-to-trial conversion rose 72%.

The redesign also framed the yearly plan as the better deal with “SAVE 40%,” compared monthly and yearly side by side, and displayed an effective monthly breakdown ($2.49/month) for the yearly plan. A 5-star review and a fun fact (86% of users improved their diet) built credibility before pricing. The original paywall had a 90% user improvement stat, but it was buried in the layout.

Which lever moved which metric

Use this comparison to choose a first test. The metric column matters: a lever that lifts trial starts may not lift revenue, and a lever that lifts paywall-view conversion may not change ARPU.

Platform note on trial toggles

Three of the four redesigns used a trial toggle. As of February 2026, Apple was rejecting iOS apps that use a free trial toggle on their paywalls. For iOS, consider the other levers in these cases or toggle-adjacent options. On Android, the toggle remains available. Treat this as a dated platform condition and check current App Store review guidance before building.

A pre-test checklist

Before running a paywall test, answer these questions:

  1. Which metric will decide the test: paywall-view conversion, install-to-trial rate, ARPU, or revenue?
  2. What is your current subscription mix across weekly, monthly, and annual plans?
  3. What is your average purchase value and ARPU today?
  4. Does your onboarding already explain the product’s value, or is the paywall doing that work?
  5. Is the lever you want to test available on your platform?
  6. Will the test isolate one lever, or will several changes ship together?

A well-known tactic can lift one metric while hurting another. For example, a timeline paywall might raise trial starts but reduce other revenue measures. Define the decision metric before you ship.

What the four cases have in common

The recurring pattern is not a single layout. It is a shorter path from value to price: less repeated text, clearer plan framing, and credibility placed where the decision happens. The cases also show that the same lever can be measured differently. A trial toggle appeared in three redesigns, but the reported outcomes were ARPU, install-to-trial rate, and revenue. Treat the numbers as dated evidence from specific apps, not a forecast for yours.

Case comparison: lever and reported metric
CaseApp categoryMain redesign leversReported metricReported result
1Crypto portfolio trackerFamiliar trading language, visible price chart, “Back to $15.99/month” marker, bold gradients, “SALE” callout, insider-tip copyPaywall-view conversion2.7% to 3.24%, over 20% improvement
2Driver-license prepTrial toggle, shorter layout, real App Store reviews, weekly plan on main screen, weekly-first price anchoringARPU17.02% boost
3Party gameTrial toggle, short-form layout, monthly plan moved to “View All Plans,” playful headline, “SAVE 83%,” price breakdownInstall-to-trial conversion and revenue31% increase in install-to-trial; 64% revenue uplift
4Food appTrial toggle, shorter layout, real App Store reviews, impact fact, “SAVE 40%,” monthly vs. yearly comparisonInstall-to-trial conversion72% increase

These are reported results from four specific apps. The metrics are not directly comparable across cases, and the figures are dated evidence rather than a forecast.

Frequently asked questions

Why do the four cases report different metrics?

Each app measured the outcome it was optimizing. The crypto app reported paywall-view conversion, the driver-license app reported ARPU, the party game reported install-to-trial conversion and revenue, and the food app reported install-to-trial conversion. A lift in one metric does not automatically mean a lift in another.

Can I still use a trial toggle on iOS?

As of February 2026, Apple was rejecting iOS apps that use a free trial toggle on their paywalls. For iOS, consider the other levers in these cases or toggle-adjacent options. On Android, the toggle remains available. Check current App Store review guidance before building.

Which paywall lever should I test first?

Start with the metric you need to move. If trial starts are the problem, test a shorter layout or clearer plan framing. If upfront revenue is the problem, test a trial toggle where your platform allows it. If users hesitate at the price, test price anchoring and social proof placement. Define one decision metric before shipping.