Skip to content
AppDues
Log in
Contact salesSign up

Choosing a North Star Metric for subscription growth

Revenue alone and total subscriber count alone can both point a subscription team in the wrong direction. A useful North Star Metric should show whether customers are receiving lasting value and whether the business is becoming healthier over time, not merely whether a short-term target was hit.

Why revenue or subscriber count alone misleads

A North Star Metric is meant to capture value shared by customers and the company. Judging success only by revenue can encourage aggressive upselling, discount-led monthly targets, and neglect of slower retention work. Revenue still matters as a directional check: if it moves the wrong way, investigate profitability and underlying drivers over time.

Total subscribers has a similar weakness. A larger base may contain many people who have not used the product recently, are unlikely to refer others, and are likely to cancel. Counting them equally can make growth look stronger than it is and discourage useful re-engagement because churn among inactive accounts is treated as a loss rather than an expected outcome.

Consider two similar apps charging the same price. App A has 40,000 subscribers and App B has 35,000. Splitting each base into inactive, low-engaged and high-engaged groups reverses the picture: App A has 22,000 inactive, 9,000 low-engaged and 9,000 high-engaged subscribers, while App B has 10,500 inactive, 12,000 low-engaged and 17,000 high-engaged subscribers. Using illustrative lifetime values of £40, £65 and £120 for those groups gives App A £2,545,000 and App B £3,240,000. The smaller app therefore has the larger potential value, with better prospects for retention and referral.

1. Active subscribers

Active subscribers count only paying customers who meet a defined activity threshold in a chosen period. This focuses attention on the people most likely to stay, spend over time and refer others, and it gives acquisition, onboarding, retention and referral teams a shared target.

The hard part is defining activity without excluding loyal people who use the product infrequently but derive great value when they do. A wellness example in the evidence used at least twice in 14 days for the most engaged group, while another loyal group used the app only once every month or two and remained subscribed for years. The threshold should reflect the main job the product does and the behaviour that drives most monetisation.

This metric does not distinguish revenue per subscriber or subscription tier. It may favour longer plans because they make targets easier to reach, but it gives little reason to move equally active customers to a higher tier. That limitation matters for tiered products.

2. Core-usage metrics

Core-usage metrics measure total engagement with the central value of the product rather than counting how many people crossed an activity threshold. Examples include listening time, messages sent, files uploaded or meetings hosted. More use is treated as more delivered value, which can strengthen retention and help new customers reach the product's main benefit.

The risk is separation from payment. Heavy use by free users does not by itself sustain a freemium business, and repeated prompts to engage can become exhausting. A core-usage target can also concentrate effort on already active customers while giving new customers less attention because they contribute fewer events.

3. Active users

Active users combine paid and free customers who meet an activity definition. This is most relevant where a free tier or trial is central and where engaged free users may later convert or recommend the product. Counting each person once, rather than every action, reduces some pressure to push constant engagement.

It remains distant from monetisation and can still flatten important differences: a lightly active account and a deeply committed one may count the same. A banking example shows the problem clearly — someone who deposits money and then does nothing else can appear active even though the account is becoming dormant. A stronger version asks whether the product has become a primary part of the person's routine, such as receiving pay, paying bills or handling regular spending.

4. Net returning revenue

Net Returning Revenue looks at revenue from existing customers over a period after returns, discounts and allowances. It rewards retention, expansion and higher-value plans, and it can be negative when churn outweighs upsells and other gains.

For tiered products, this measure gives a reason to improve the experience and retention of higher tiers rather than simply adding subscribers. Its weaknesses are complexity and distance from customer value: refunds and revenue timing can make measurement difficult, new customers are excluded, and inactive subscribers who forget to cancel can still contribute revenue.

5. Realized lifetime value per paying customer

Realized Lifetime Value per Paying Customer divides actual revenue, minus refunds, from a customer cohort by the number of customers in that cohort. It supports retention, upselling and profitable acquisition because it shows how much value a paying customer has already generated.

Used with trial conversion and broken down by country, it can inform how much can be paid to acquire a customer. It is nevertheless a lagging indicator: realized value may take months to reveal whether changes worked. It also does not prove that customers are active or receiving value, since forgotten or unused annual subscriptions can raise spend. Combining per-customer value with customer count gives total lifetime value and a fuller view of growth.

How to choose

Active subscribers suit apps with clear recurring use and no freemium model. Core-usage metrics suit products whose value depends on high activity. Active users suit freemium or trial products where conversion may take time. Net returning revenue suits tiered pricing and upsell opportunities. Realized lifetime value suits products with high values and longer retention cycles.

Before adopting a candidate, run these checks:

  • Can every department explain the metric in the same way?
  • Can the target be reached while the company still fails?
  • Does it reward only short-term growth or only acquisition?
  • Is it easy to measure regularly?
  • Will it remain meaningful for years?
  • Does it cover the full funnel, from first value through retention and referral?

A strong North Star Metric differs by product, but the common requirement is balance: it should reflect value for customers and financial health for the company at the same time.