Skip to content
AppDues
Log in
Contact salesSign up

Mobile subscription predictions: payments, regulation and growth

This outlook, originally published in January 2022, surveys the forces shaping subscription apps: app store payment rules, country-by-country regulation, mixed revenue models, gaming subscriptions, privacy-driven attribution and emerging app categories. Treat it as a dated reference for planning, not a forecast of current conditions.

In-app payment rules

The central question going into 2022 was whether developers could charge users through external payment systems for in-app purchases. The outlook was that no major shift would arrive quickly, and that third-party payment providers would not be broadly permitted in the near term.

What did change was communication: Apple had already been pushed to accept messaging about alternative payment methods outside the app, for example by email. Building web flows to onboard and charge users before an app install was expected to become a more standard complement to IAP subscriptions.

Even if platforms were forced to allow third-party payments in-app, permission is not the same as benefit. External payments add complexity, and platforms can charge a commission on them — Google already did so in Korea. If a commission applies to non-IAP transactions, the expected savings can disappear. In-app purchases are usually associated with higher conversions, a better user experience and less financial overhead, which can outweigh a small fee difference.

Regulatory burdens and fragmentation

Payment debates often fixate on fees while overlooking adjacent constraints. App store rules also impose technical limits; more flexible guidelines could allow apps that cannot exist under current rules.

The cost may go beyond economics. Separate government rulings can fragment guidelines, which is difficult for developers serving a global audience. Apple applied its settlement with the Japanese Fair Trade Commission globally rather than only in Japan, aiming to keep one set of App Store rules across markets. Google created a separate system for South Korean developers to pay a commission on third-party in-app payments. Similar pressure was expected for dating apps in the Netherlands.

Compliance work can be pushed onto developers, adding complexity to building for a global audience. As with GDPR, some teams may choose not to serve certain countries rather than manage complicated rules.

Hybrid revenue models

Most apps monetize exclusively with subscriptions or not at all, with news and some entertainment apps as notable exceptions. Over the longer term, hybrid models were expected to appear: subscriptions remain the core driver but are supplemented by additional streams, loosening the “high floor, low ceiling” pattern.

For new or non-premium subscribers, that could mean ads or non-renewable in-app purchases such as daily or weekly passes. For premium subscribers, add-ons might include branded goods and e-shops (for example Sweat), affiliate marketplaces and partnership revenue (for example Fishbrain), multiple subscription bundles (for example Reflectly), and advanced features such as paid live video coaching or IP-based exclusive content unlocked on top of a subscription, similar to DLC in video games.

Gaming apps and subscriptions

Games have historically monetized well without subscriptions, using ad-driven revenue at the lower end, “whale” IAP offerings at the higher end, and affordable non-renewable IAP in between. A recurring flat fee was not common and was not expected to be widely adopted or to replace ads and non-renewable charges.

Recurring payments were seen as a possible complement. For games with long-term narratives and broad buy-in, a subscription could unlock new content and features regularly, keeping players engaged while monetizing part of live-ops updates.

Growth trends

Privacy-driven attribution was expected to settle gradually. In 2021 developers adjusted to uncertainty and used modeling to measure ad spend impact; older user-level methods were simpler and more efficient but carried privacy implications. Apple had updated its privacy rules, and Google was expected to move to opt-in eventually, though timing was uncertain.

Advertisers and publishers had already been constrained to change practices, while ad networks had not. The hope was that networks would adjust their products toward more privacy-respecting performance. In the meantime, advertisers diversified away from the Facebook and Google duopoly. Influencer marketing was a major disruptor, with new brand–creator collaboration models beyond sponsored content, such as TikTok Spark Ads.

Growth is not only paid acquisition. With some loss in user acquisition and re-marketing efficiency, apps that relied on paid acquisition and hard paywalls were expected to consider a model widely adopted in prior years: removing the hard paywall to retain more users and open up the AARRR (acquisition, activation, retention, referral, revenue) journey. Those that do should see lower churn and higher virality, and may shift marketing resources from standard acquisition channels to organic efforts — a boost for branding, virality, community and new monetization beyond the paywall. The result would be a more sustainable acquisition mix and a longer-term view.

App categories to watch

Photo and video editors and productivity apps had shown strong growth, with new ideas demonstrating impressive trajectory (for example PhotoRoom’s traction in 2021).

Two categories blurring the classic B2C/B2B line were expected to stand out:

  • Tools for content creators (for example CapCut).
  • Apps for independent workers and small businesses, making invoicing and communication easier on mobile.

Health, fitness and meditation apps had long dominated the subscription market, feeding a wave of personal development and health apps with new value propositions: improving sleep quality (Rise), holistic health (Vital), CBT (Bloom), twists on what Blinkist pioneered (Lucid, Uptime), and professional development (Bunch).

“After Tinder” apps — pocket coaches for improving relationships (like Paired) — were expected to have strong tailwinds. Web3 and NFTs had buzz but poor UX held back mainstream adoption; breakout apps were expected.

One example: Tacter operates at the frontier of gaming, crypto, subscriptions and personal coaching, helping gamers improve at titles such as League of Legends or Axie Infinity. With Play2Earn games, a subscription-based coach can bring value to populations in lower-earning countries that are not usually the primary audience for subscription apps. Challenges remain, since decentralization may not always fit the platform-ruled app environment — and not only for payment reasons. Reaching users through the device they hold all day is the clearest path to mainstream crypto adoption.

Decision checklist for planning

Use this checklist to turn the outlook into a planning conversation:

  1. Payment path: If you add external payment flows, model the platform commission and compare it with the conversion and UX advantages of IAP.
  2. Regulatory exposure: List the countries you serve and flag any country-specific billing rules that could apply.
  3. Revenue mix: Identify one supplementary stream (ads, passes, bundles, add-ons) that fits your current subscriber base.
  4. Gaming fit: For games, test a subscription as a complement to ads and non-renewable IAP, not a replacement.
  5. Attribution: Confirm which measurement methods remain viable under current privacy rules before committing ad spend.
  6. Paywall: If acquisition efficiency has dropped, evaluate whether a softer paywall improves retention and virality.
  7. Category: Check whether your product sits in a category with strong tailwinds (creator tools, small-business tools, health and personal development, relationship coaching).

Frequently asked questions

Will developers be able to use third-party payment providers for in-app purchases?

The 2022 outlook was that no significant change would arrive quickly and that third-party payment providers would not be broadly allowed in the near term. Even if allowed, platforms can charge a commission on external transactions — Google already did so in Korea — which can erase the expected benefit. In-app purchases are usually associated with higher conversions, a better user experience and less financial overhead.

Why does regulatory fragmentation matter for subscription apps?

Separate government rulings can produce country-specific rules. Apple applied its Japanese Fair Trade Commission settlement globally to keep one set of App Store rules, while Google created a separate system for South Korean developers to pay commission on third-party in-app payments. Compliance work can fall on developers, and some teams may choose not to serve certain countries rather than manage complicated regulations.

What does a hybrid revenue model look like for a subscription app?

Subscriptions stay the core driver, supplemented by other streams. For new or non-premium subscribers that could mean ads or non-renewable in-app purchases such as daily or weekly passes. For premium subscribers it could mean branded goods and e-shops, affiliate marketplaces and partnership revenue, multiple subscription bundles, or advanced features such as paid live video coaching or IP-based exclusive content unlocked on top of a subscription.

Should games replace ads and in-app purchases with subscriptions?

No. The outlook was that a recurring flat fee would not be widely adopted and would not replace ads and non-renewable charges. A subscription could complement existing revenue streams, especially for games with long-term narratives and broad buy-in, by unlocking new content and features regularly and monetizing part of live-ops updates.

Why would an app remove its hard paywall?

With some loss in user acquisition and re-marketing efficiency, apps that relied on paid acquisition and hard paywalls were expected to consider removing the hard paywall to retain more users and open up the AARRR (acquisition, activation, retention, referral, revenue) journey. Those that do should see lower churn and higher virality, and may shift marketing resources from standard acquisition channels to organic efforts.