Skip to content
AppDues
Log in
Contact salesSign up

Subscription app benchmarking with the Subscription Value Loop

A benchmarking tool built around the Subscription Value Loop is designed to turn subscription performance data into specific growth opportunities. Instead of presenting isolated numbers, it organises comparison points around how an app creates value, delivers that value, and captures it as revenue.

A framework that points to opportunities, not just numbers

The tool was created with Phil Carter, founder of Elemental Growth and creator of the Subscription Value Loop framework. Its purpose is to move beyond raw figures and highlight where an app can improve.

The framework divides subscription growth into three stages:

  • Value Creation: how well the app solves user problems and delivers its core promise.
  • Value Delivery: how efficiently users are connected with that value.
  • Value Capture: how effectively created value is converted into subscription revenue.

Mapping benchmarks to those stages makes the result actionable. A low conversion rate, for example, points toward a different intervention than weak retention or an acquisition cost that is high relative to lifetime value.

Large-scale data behind the comparisons

The benchmarks draw on large-scale subscription app data, described as billions of dollars of subscription activity and an updated dataset connected to the State of Subscription Apps report. That scale is intended to make comparisons more current and representative than a small or manually assembled sample.

For practical use, treat the dataset as a reference frame rather than a verdict. Check whether the comparison group matches your category and geography, then look for the stage of the value loop where your app diverges most from comparable performers.

What to compare in your own app

Use the benchmark as a diagnostic checklist:

  • Compare user acquisition costs with similar apps in the same category.
  • Review conversion rates at each stage of the user journey, not only at purchase.
  • Compare retention with strong performers in the same field.
  • Test whether pricing fits the market and the value delivered.
  • Filter every comparison by category and geographic focus before drawing conclusions.

That sequence helps prioritise work. If acquisition is efficient but conversion drops late in the journey, pricing and packaging deserve attention first. If conversion is strong but retention lags comparable apps, the core promise or ongoing value delivery may be the constraint.

Why developer input was requested

Developer input was sought through a short survey estimated at three minutes. Responses were intended to strengthen benchmarks for acquisition cost and lifetime value, two areas that are difficult to benchmark from subscription transaction data alone. If you are evaluating a similar benchmarking effort, ask what participation involves, how the collected figures will be used, and whether any incentive or early-access arrangement is documented in writing before you take part.

Related events announced at the time

A webinar on Wednesday, August 28, 2024, at 8:00 AM featured Phil Carter discussing growth beyond $10 million in revenue. Topics included cost-efficient user acquisition, pricing and packaging for conversion and retention, and applying the Subscription Value Loop to growth strategy. For any comparable session, confirm the date, time zone, format and registration terms directly with the organiser before planning attendance. A separate App Growth Annual conference was scheduled for September 25, 2024, for 200 app growth professionals, with in-person attendance in San Francisco and a virtual option. Phil Carter was listed as the opening keynote speaker on sustainable app growth. Check the event's current schedule, venue and access options with its organiser, since published details can change.

Subscription Value Loop diagnostic map
StageDiagnostic questionBenchmark focus
Value CreationDoes the app solve the problem and deliver its core promise?Retention and user value
Value DeliveryHow efficiently are users connected with that value?Acquisition cost and journey conversion
Value CaptureHow effectively is value converted into subscription revenue?Pricing, conversion and lifetime value

Use category and geography filters before comparing against other apps.

Frequently asked questions

What does the Subscription Value Loop framework measure?

The framework separates growth into three linked stages: creating value by solving a user problem and delivering the core promise, delivering that value efficiently to users, and capturing it as subscription revenue. A benchmark mapped to those stages shows whether a weakness sits in the product promise, distribution, or monetisation rather than treating every metric as the same problem.

Why compare by category and geography?

Category and geography matter because acquisition costs, conversion, retention and pricing expectations differ by market. Comparing only against similar apps in the same category and geographic focus gives a more useful reference point than a single global average.

What was the survey meant to add, and what did respondents receive?

The survey was intended to add benchmarks for acquisition cost and lifetime value. Respondents were offered early access before general release and entry into a draw for one of five $100 USD gift cards.