Epic vs. Apple Supreme Court ruling: what it means for US app monetization
In January 2024 the US Supreme Court declined to hear the appeals in Epic Games v. Apple, leaving the lower-court anti-steering outcome in place. For US iOS developers that means a narrow, approved route to link out for payment — with a commission, strict placement rules and added user friction that change the business case.
What the January 2024 decision changed for US users
After the Supreme Court declined to hear the appeals in January 2024, the lower court's anti-steering ruling stood. US developers can now direct users to alternative payment methods outside the App Store, but only through Apple's approved entitlement system and only in the USA. The earlier part of the injunction — communicating alternative purchase options outside the app, such as by email — had already been implemented in 2021, so the remaining practical change concerns linking from inside the app.
A practical checklist for the external purchase link
Use this checklist before deciding whether to build the entitlement: 1) Apply and obtain approval for the StoreKit External Purchase Link Entitlement (US). 2) Place exactly one link in one place in the app — not in a popup or interstitial, and not on the in-app purchase screen. 3) Open a new browser window rather than a web view, and do not pass extra data such as the user ID. 4) Expect Apple's disclosure sheet when the API is called. 5) Budget for Apple's commission on qualifying purchases within seven days of the tap, plus your payment processor's fee. 6) Set up monthly accounting of qualifying out-of-app purchases, due within 15 days after month end, even in months with no transactions, and be ready for audit.
Why the margin math often does not work
Worked example: a developer compares in-app purchase with the external route. In-app purchase keeps checkout inside the app with Face ID or Touch ID. The external route adds a disclosure confirmation, a fresh website login because user data cannot be passed through, and manual card entry, then adds a processor fee of roughly 3% on top of Apple's 27% commission (or 12% where the reduced rate applies). On those numbers the external route can cost about the same as in-app purchase before accounting for lower conversion from the extra steps and the monthly reporting overhead. That is why web acquisition or email campaigns — where the user is already on the web — are often a cleaner way to pursue web margins than an in-app external link.
How developers reacted
Epic's CEO called the compliance plan anticompetitive, and other developers and commentators criticised the 27% commission, reporting burden and audit right. The criticism centres on whether Apple's implementation undermines the injunction's purpose — allowing buttons, external links or other calls to action directing customers to purchasing mechanisms in addition to in-app purchase.
How the case got here
The dispute began in August 2020 when Epic added a direct payment option to Fortnite with a user discount, bypassing Apple and Google payment systems. Fortnite was removed from the stores and Epic sued, alleging antitrust and anticompetitive behaviour. Epic ran a #FreeFortnite campaign and a parody of Apple's 1984 commercial; Apple threatened to terminate Epic's developer accounts, which would also have affected Unreal Engine apps, prompting Epic to seek a temporary restraining order. The court largely sided with Apple on monopoly, but objected to anti-steering restrictions and ordered Apple to allow external purchase links and outside-app communication of alternatives. Both sides appealed, and the Supreme Court's January 2024 refusal to hear the appeals made the lower rulings permanent.
Lessons from South Korea and the Netherlands
South Korea updated its Telecommunication Business Act to require app store operators to allow third-party payment systems. In late 2023 the Korea Communications Commission said restricting developers to certain payment methods and discriminatory fee charging undermined the law's fair-competition purpose, and native in-app purchase volume still grew significantly from 2021 to 2023. In the Netherlands, the Authority for Consumers and Markets investigated dating apps specifically; the resulting policy goes further than the US rule by allowing an external payment provider inside the app, but still requires permission, earnings reporting, a 27% or 12% commission and an Apple warning modal, with part of compliance still in Dutch litigation.
What to expect next
Expect slow, incremental change rather than a sudden shift of in-app purchase revenue to external payments: challenging Apple's implementation takes time, the original decision expressly allowed Apple to charge a commission for web purchases, and external links offer minimal upside once commissions, administrative overhead and lower conversion are counted. Epic has indicated the fight will continue, and the case may influence other regions, including the European Union's Digital Markets Act.
| Item | In-app purchase | External purchase link (US) |
|---|---|---|
| Where checkout happens | Inside the app | On an external website in a new browser window |
| Placement | In-app purchase screen | One link in one place; not on paywall, popup or interstitial |
| User data passed | Native checkout | No additional information such as user ID |
| Apple commission | Standard in-app purchase commission | 27%, or 12% for Small Business Program and subscriptions after first year, within 7 days of tap |
| Extra cost | — | Payment processor fee, about 3% in the source example |
| Reporting | Standard | Monthly accounting within 15 days after month end; audit possible |
Summary of terms as described in the source material; verify current Apple terms before acting.
Frequently asked questions
What does the US external purchase link allow?
US developers may, after approval, place one external purchase link in one place in the app to direct users to a website for purchasing. It cannot be in a popup, interstitial or in-app purchase screen, must open a new browser window, and cannot pass additional information such as a user ID.
What commission and reporting apply to external purchases?
Apple charges 27% on qualifying external transactions, or 12% for Small Business Program developers and subscriptions after their first year. The commission applies to purchases within seven days of tapping the external purchase link, and developers must report qualifying purchases monthly within 15 days after month end, subject to audit.
Why might external purchase links not improve margins?
The economics are tight because a typical payment processor adds about 3% on top of Apple's commission, leaving little or no margin advantage over in-app purchase, while extra steps — confirming a disclosure, logging in again, and entering card details instead of using Face ID or Touch ID — add friction that can lower conversion.
What happened in South Korea and the Netherlands?
In South Korea, regulators said limited payment choices and fee practices undermined the law's purpose, and native in-app purchase volume still grew significantly from 2021 to 2023. In the Netherlands, dating apps gained broader in-app external payment options, but with application, reporting, 27% or 12% commission and a warning modal, and compliance remained partly in litigation.